If you've used some of the newer Internet facilities -- such as graphical
World Wide Web browsers or CU-
video conferencing -- over a modem connection, you realize that accessing the
Internet at current modem data rates provides barely adequate performance. As applications become more sophisticated and require more bandwidth, this
situation will only worsen. And if you're putting an entire corporate LAN on
the Internet, a modem connection becomes a serious bottleneck. Unfortunately,
the current crop of high-speed modems, running at 28.8 Kbps, are about as fast as modems will ever get. That's
because a physical speed barrier exists at 30 Kbps -- a barrier that can't be
broken without abandoning the modem's analog signaling for something completely
different (see see
Truth About High-Speed Modems).
That "completely different" something is digital signaling, in the form of Integrated Services Digital Network (ISDN). Using the same copper phone lines that modems use, ISDN delivers a five-fold speed improvement (up to 128 Kbps) and provides essentially perfect transmission reliability. And ISDN can mesh into other digital technologies, such as Frame Relay and ATM, making possible future speeds several times higher even than 128 Kbps.
The "Integrated" part of ISDN's name refers to the combining of voice and data services over the same wires (so computers can connect directly to the telephone network without first converting their signals to an analog audio signal, as modems do). This integration brings with it a host of new capabilities combining voice, data, fax, and sophisticated switching. And because ISDN uses the existing local telephone wiring, it's equally available to home and business customers. Most important for Internet users, however, is that ISDN provides a huge improvement in access speed at only a fractional increase in cost.
ISDN service is available today in most major metropolitan areas and probably will be completely deployed throughout the U.S. by the end of 1995. Many Internet Service Providers (ISPs) now sell ISDN access -- some for little more than you'd currently pay for modem access (about $1/hr). To find out if ISDN will work for you, you need to understand the capabilities ISDN offers, how it delivers them, and what it all costs in equipment and fees.
Figure 1 shows a minimal ISDN setup connecting two computers. The incoming twisted pair enters a telco-provided box called the network terminator (NT1), which breaks the 144 Kbps channel into the two B and single D subchannels. (If you're wondering how ISDN squeezes 144 Kbps out of the same twisted pair that modems struggle with at 28.8 Kbps, read see How ISDN Does It).
The B channels carry customer voice or data signals. The D channel carries signals between your ISDN equipment and the phone company's central office. The two bearer plus one data channel is called the Basic Rate Interface (BRI) in telco lingo, or sometimes just 2B+D for short. You also can buy ISDN in bulk: 23 B channels with a single 64 Kbps D channel. This service, called the Primary Rate Interface (PRI), inherits most of the capabilities and limitations of BRI, so what you learn about 2B+D applies to PRI's 23B+D service, as well.
Continuing with Figure 1, a single four-wire cable carries the 2B+D channels to another box called the Terminal Adapter (TA). Unlike the NT1, which provides only a single function (creating the 2B+D channels), the TA can do many things. Its job is to connect any and all of your Terminal Equipment (TE) -- computers, fax machines, LANs, or telephone sets -- to one or both of the B channels. Depending on the variety of terminal equipment you want to connect, the TA might be cheap or expensive, simple or complex. In this example, the TA is shown as a separate unit, but it could easily be contained within the computer (as an add-in card or integrated feature) or integrated with the NT1 into a single box as a modem replacement or stand-alone TCP/IP router. ISDN's current popularity is stimulating the introduction of new TAs regularly.
Figure 1 also shows the external ISDN reference points, labeled R, S/T, and U. (Don't strain yourself trying to deduce what R, S, T, and U stand for -- they are simply consecutive letters of the alphabet, chosen by the ITU -- The International Telegraphic Union, a standards-setting body -- as the next available designations from the entire set of ITU standards.) Each interface point requires an electrically different device connection and cabling. The U reference point is the incoming unshielded twisted pair (UTP); the S/T reference point is a four-wire UTP cable.
A typical TA for data-only applications might simply emulate a pair of ordinary (albeit very fast) Hayes-compatible modems, translating standard modem setup and dialing commands into ISDN call-setup commands. You connect your computer to this kind of TA with a normal RS-232 cable and use your usual modem or fax software set to 64 Kbps (or as high as you can go). The TA provides automatic rate adaptation to match whatever data rate your computer supports with ISDN's 64 Kbps channel, so that if your computer can't communicate faster than, say, 38.4 Kbps, it will still work fine under ISDN (and even connect properly to a remote computer operating at some other speed). An example of a more sophisticated TA is the ISDN router, which connects to an ISDN line on one side and your office or home LAN on the other. An ISDN router can carry your network traffic -- AppleTalk, IPX, TCP/IP -- either down the street to your main office or around the world on the Internet. The advantage of an ISDN router over the simpler modem-replacement TA is the ability to support many different kinds of computers without special ISDN software; the router contains all the intelligence necessary to move traffic over an ISDN link, literally moving your local LAN to the far-away destination of your choice.
"But wait!" you cry. "All you've done so far is replace modems with a lot of extra boxes and wires. If this is all ISDN offers, what good is it?" Remember, the example in Figure 1 is a minimal ISDN setup. Even with this bare-bones configuration, though, you're getting the equivalent of two 64 Kbps modems, two telephone lines, and virtually guaranteed reliable data transport. This last item is an important advantage over analog modems, which suffer from all kinds of maladies ranging from intermittent line noise to speed mismatches and protocol conflicts.
Because ISDN is purely digital, the telco can more easily deliver data intact from end to end, largely eliminating the effects of noise. And because the 64 Kbps channel is essentially a pure "bit pipe," with no rate negotiation or handshaking involved, there are no modem speed or protocol differences to cause conflicts. In fact, because the negotiation phase with ISDN is so simple, ISDN takes only a second or two to dial and establish a connection (modems may take as long as a minute to accomplish the same thing). These benefits alone are worth the cost of two high-speed modems, which is about what a bare-bones TA costs.
In an Internet-access application, your computer treats the basic TA just as it would a modem, using the PPP (Point-to-Point) serial line protocol to carry your Internet traffic. From your point of view, then, the ISDN connection setup is identical to the setup a PPP modem Internet connection. Although you could technically run the popular SLIP (Serial Line Internet Protocol) over ISDN, PPP is the ISDN transport protocol of choice for several reasons. First, PPP is built into a number of ISDN-capable routers on the market, and your ISP will likely be using one of these routers to provide ISDN dialup service. Second, a variant of PPP, called MPP (for Multichannel Point-to-Point Protocol) lets you combine the two 64 Kbps D channels to create one 128 Kbps bonded channel. This is also called inverse multiplexing, and is usually set up to provide bandwidth on demand -- only adding the second channel when network traffic warrants. Bandwidth-on-demand is a cost-saving feature. Each D-channel ISDN connection is treated as a separate phone call, so having two channels up costs twice as much as one if your ISDN connection has per-minute usage fees associated with it. For flat-rate ISDN calls, you can permanently bond the D channels.
Figure 2 shows a passive bus with a dozen computers and four fax machines sharing an ISDN circuit. You need one TA for every two pieces of terminal equipment. Whenever a computer or fax machine wants to use a B channel, its associated TA checks to see if a channel is available, and, if so, dedicates it to the requesting TE. The example shows maximum device sharing, but the cost of additional 2B+D circuits is low enough that you'll likely have fewer devices on a single bus.
An alternative to using an external TA is to connect your computer to ISDN directly. You can get adapters for PC, Mac, and RISC systems providing direct ISDN connectivity, and some systems, such as the Sun Sparcstation, have integrated ISDN built in. Along with the adapter, you need software supporting ISDN's call control protocols. Most integrated ISDN products include basic software providing the equivalent of "dumb" TA functionality. You can add options for fax, image, and even video conferencing features. In isolation, these capabilities may not seem useful, but combined with another ISDN feature -- call appearances -- they let you construct sophisticated integrated voice/data applications.
"on hold" while taking or making a second call, provide two call appearances -- the call you're talking on and the call on hold. ISDN expands that capability to up to 15 separate calls (Figure 3).
For incoming ISDN calls, the telco's Central Office (CO) sends a call setup message to the TA via the D channel, indicating that a call is available to be picked up (if multiple TAs are connected via passive bus, any TA can pick up the call). The TA can answer the call and assign it to an available B channel, or, if both B channels are in use, it can free a channel by placing an active call on hold and making the new call active. These calls can be either data or voice, in any combination. Thus, a single TA could have as many as 15 simultaneous calls in progress, with any two of those calls active (i.e., actually communicating).
If the TA is a personal computer, it can act as a sort of mini-PBX, making possible all sorts of sophisticated call-handling applications. You can transfer calls from one B channel to another (or among 23 B channels on ISDN PRI service), join two or more calls together in a conference, hold active calls, resume held calls, retrieve calling-number identification data, even forward calls to a completely unrelated telephone number (which might not be an ISDN circuit). In practice, multiple call appearances are more useful for voice than data calls, and most data-capable ISDN TAs only support multiple appearances if they also support voice features. Still, the call appearance concept is important in bandwidth-on-demand applications, where one TA might combine both B channels to obtain a 128 Kbps data pipe but relinquish one B channel to answer an incoming call from another location.
The data applications of ISDN shown so far all require that both parties in the connection have ISDN or packet data service. What if you need to connect with somebody that isn't ISDN capable? The answer is that you use your good ol' analog modem (you didn't throw away your modems yet, did you?) and a TA that supports analog voice connections, or POTS (Figure 4).
This kind of TA accepts an ordinary voice or modem audio signal through a standard RJ11 modular jack and digitizes it for transport across the ISDN interface. It interprets the touch-tone dialing signals put out by your telephone set or modem and generates the required ISDN call-setup signals. If the number you're calling isn't an ISDN POP, the telco equipment at the remote end automatically translates the digitized audio back to analog audio, where the destination modem (or human being) hears what it's always heard before ISDN came along.
This might seem like a terribly roundabout way of maintaining backwards compatibility. It is. But even if ISDN achieves its goal of 95% deployment by the end of 1995, there still will be hundreds of thousands of U.S. modem/fax users, not to mention overseas modems and fax machines. In fact, some ISDN TAs include built-in analog modems (sometimes anomalously called "digital modems") just to provide compatibility with existing analog fax and data devices. So plan on keeping your modems around at least until the end of the decade; you'll still need them occasionally. Fortunately, many TAs provide POTS ports without much additional cost, so this is a painless necessity.
Many telcos are pricing ISDN similarly to a normal business telephone line, with measured service charges for the time you're actually using the circuit (plus normal long-distance charges when they apply). The cheapest service (PacBell's) runs $30 per month for local access plus message-unit charges of four cents for the first minute and one cent for each additional minute. If the call is long distance, you'll also pay long-distance digital charges, which can be two to three times higher than voice long-distance calls (although competition is rapidly bringing these costs down). Even the most expensive ISDN providers have monthly rates below $100, and many have options that eliminate message-unit charges. For example, PacBell's "Home ISDN" package charges message units only between 8am and 5pm on non-holiday weekdays.
The NT1 costs between $100 and $200, but often you can find TAs with the NT1 device built in. ISDN TAs range in price from as little as $300 for data-only units providing Hayes-compatible modem emulation to $1,500 or more for ISDN-capable routers that can interconnect LANs over ISDN. Standalone TAs often cost less than bus-specific plug-in cards and are usable across a wider range of computer systems. And ISDN routers, which don't depend on your host computer's serial port capabilities, are even more flexable than stand-alone TAs. Unless you have a tightly-coupled ISDN application that requires a plug-in card, you're better off with standalone devices. And unless you're certain you'll never need to connect more than a single computer to the Internet, an ISDN router is a better investment than a serial-port TA that requires host-specific software to operate.
The ITU recommendation for 28,000 bps modems, called V.34, specifies a signaling standard designed to work reliably on most PSTN voice-grade lines. The operative word in that standard is most: There are still many local phone companies in the U.S. where V.34 won't operate or where the overall quality of a long-distance connection is too poor for V.34. In such cases, V.32 can fall back to a slower speed -- 20,000, 14,400, 9600, 4800, or even 2400 bps.
A separate recommendation, V.42, defines an error detection and correction protocol for modems that lets the modems themselves ensure reliable, error-free data transport. A modem with both V.34 and V.42 capabilities is a handy thing because it removes from the attached computers the responsibility of routine error handling. Given that error-correcting modems provide guaranteed data transport, CCITT decided that the modem was also a good place to perform data compression and released the V.42bis (from the Latin bis for second) recommendation in 1990. The data compression algorithm used in V.42bis modems has the potential for achieving as much as a four-fold decrease in data volume. In real life, though, compression depends on the data; only in rare cases does it ever reach even 50 percent, and then only with plain-text data. The more forthright vendors report their 28,800 bps modems as running at 28,800 bps. Other vendors go for the gusto, multiplying 28,800 bps times two or four to get 56,000 or 112,000 bps.
There is another reason to look upon modem compression with jaundiced eye: It turns out that the modem wasn't such a good place to put compression, after all. It seemed like a good idea back when computer users ignored security and plain text was most often the data of choice. Now, however, users are turning to host-based encryption and compression to both protect their data and get better data reduction. Host-based compression algorithms have advanced beyond the original V.42bis recommendation and generally give higher compression ratios than modems. Also, to save space in online archives, users want to store files that are already compressed.
Thus, most file transfers today are encrypted or compressed (or both) by the host and cannot be compressed any further by the modem. In fact, modem compression actually increases the amount of data when you send a previously compressed file! For most modem users, onboard compression is becoming a nuisance they want to turn off. Finally, keep in mind that (when appropriate) ISDN TAs can perform compression, too. Many ISDN-capable routers provide compression because LAN data is often compressible. If you're getting confused by all the speed and compression variables in the modem world today, remember that it all goes away with ISDN.
A given pair of wires connecting two parties for communication can carry electrical signals in one of two forms: analog or digital. An analog signal changes gradually through an infinite number of values, while a digital signal changes instantly (in theory) between just two values. The human voice and a musical instrument are examples of analog signals -- both produce complex variations in frequency and amplitude. A light switch typifies a digital signal -- it can be either on or off.
An analog signal's infinite number of variations makes it impossible to reproduce exactly. An analog signal will go only so far in copper wire; to go further the signal must be regenerated electronically with a device called a repeater. The repeater converts the weak input signal to a stronger output signal, unavoidably distorting it in the process. Each regeneration degrades the signal a bit more (in the same way that photocopies of photocopies get worse at each iteration). In a large telephone network, the "copy of a copy" problem becomes very expensive to solve, requiring sophisticated equipment and costly cabling.
Digital signals, on the other hand, are easy to regenerate precisely. Because there are only two possible states for the signal, even a heavily degraded signal can be regenerated into an exact copy of the original. What's more, the cost (and complexity) of equipment to regenerate digital signals is trivial compared with that for analog. Not surprisingly, telephone companies recognized this cost advantage a long time ago and have since converted all long distance transmission to digital signaling. When a subscriber makes a long-distance call, the central office (CO) converts the analog signal to digital using a technique called sampling (see "Analog-to-Digital Conversion Diagram"), in which the state of the analog signal is captured about 8,000 times per second. Each state is converted to an 8-bit binary number, and the resulting string of binary numbers becomes a digital data stream at 64 Kbps. This digital stream is routed along the long-distance network, being regenerated as needed. Each regeneration produces an exact copy of the original digital data stream, so no information is lost. When the destination CO receives the digital data stream, it reverses the sampling process and transmits the resulting analog signal to the receiving subscriber. (On a side note, many local telephone companies are converting to digital switching, even for local calls).
A modem can't get 64 Kbps out of an analog line because the CO's signal sampling, at 8,000 times per second, limits the bandwidth of the analog signal to about 3 kHz, which in turn invokes Shannon's Law (see "The Truth About High-Speed Modems") setting the practical speed limit for such a channel to about 30 Kbps. To get higher analog speeds requires higher fidelity in the audio signal, dictating faster sampling in the CO's analog-to-digital conversion, which would result in a digital data stream faster than 64 Kbps. Telco's aren't about to change out all their voice digitizers for faster versions or upgrade all their digital circuits to carry channels faster than 64 Kbps. So the probability of the phone system ever supporting faster analog signaling rates is zero.
This is where ISDN steps in. ISDN cuts out the middleman by eliminating the need for voice digitizers in the CO. ISDN carries through the 64 Kbps digital signal from the CO right to the subscriber, and the subscriber can use it for voice or data as required. Advances in electronics make it practical to do voice digitizing right in the subscriber's phone, and direct digital attachment of computers eliminates the need for modems.
Another alternative is to replace copper wire with fiber optic cabling, which would reach out and touch every subscriber with essentially unlimited bandwidth. There is a single overriding problem with all these alternatives: They suffer from an inability to conquer a physical barrier that telephone companies euphemistically call "The Last Mile."
The Last Mile, also called the local loop, is telco talk for the twisted wire pair between the CO and the subscriber. This part of the telephone network is virtually unchanged since Alexander Graham Bell. Each telephone user requires a dedicated pair of copper wires. The length is usually more than a mile but fewer than 20 miles and averages about five miles in metropolitan areas. Faster digital services (such as T1, fractional T1, ATM and SMDS) require digital repeaters at least once per mile. But normal copper pairs -- buried perhaps 50 years ago -- don't have such repeaters. What's worse, they often have analog conditioning equipment that actually impedes digital signals! If you want high-speed digital service, your telco will cheerfully run conditioned lines to your office -- for a hefty fee.
What about just replacing all the copper with fiber optics, as the Fiber-to-the-Home (FTTH) proponents suggest? The 130 million phone lines in the U.S. use 650 million miles of copper pairs. Considering that planet Earth is only about 93 million miles from the sun, this is a hefty amount of wire in anybody's book. According to a 1987 Bellcore study, the cost to replace all the existing copper with fiber would be $250 billion (and several decades of labor). This is about ten times what it would cost to replace every telephone switch in the U.S. with digital equipment and lines!
What about replacing just the business lines, or metropolitan area lines, with fiber? Indeed, this is what will probably happen. But even such limited deployment won't be cheap or fast (about $10,000 per subscriber -- and still requiring decades to complete). All the while, information technology will continue to decentralize the workplace, increasing the demand for faster communications.
ISDN can serve users until FTTH (or some other technology) is ready for prime time. ISDN isn't as fast as everyone would like, but it's a heck of a lot faster and cheaper than what we've got. And it's being delivered today.